Forecasting vs crystal balling: Predicting stock movements

Forecasting fortune illustration representing the ability to predict stock movements.

Learn the difference between forecasting and crystal balling in stock trading, and how to avoid wishful thinking for more effective investing.

Have you ever heard someone say, “I wish I had a crystal ball?”. This phrase often expresses the desire to know what the future holds, especially when it comes to stock trading. But let’s set the record straight: crystal balls have no place in investing! Any form of mystical, magical forecasting is not a reliable investment strategy.

While we can dismiss the concept of crystal balling, it’s important to distinguish between educated forecasting and guesswork when discussing stock trading. The difference between an informed, data-driven forecast and blindly hoping for the best could mean the difference between success and failure in the market.

The crystal balling pitfall: An example of misguided hope

Imagine a trader buys a stock at $75. Over the past year, the stock’s price has been steadily falling. The trader thinks, “It can’t go much lower” or “This is a huge discount for a good stock,” and buys in expecting a rebound. But, as often happens, the price continues to drop. The trader, thinking they’re getting an even better deal, buys more shares at $50, then $30, and then $15, believing the price must reverse soon.

As you can imagine, this strategy often ends in frustration. Even if the stock eventually turns the corner and starts rising, the trader now faces a massive challenge: for the stock to return to the initial $75 price, it must increase by 100% – a difficult feat after such a steep decline. Had the trader waited for a clear chart signal indicating a trend reversal, they could have profited much sooner.

Forecasting vs guesswork: The role of data and analysis

When forecasting stock prices, it’s essential to rely on data and analysis, not wishful thinking. Just like weather forecasts, which provide an educated guess based on patterns and information, stock price forecasts should also be rooted in facts. While we don’t expect any forecast to be perfectly accurate, we aim to be on the right side of the ledger more often than not.

Stock prices, like weather systems, are influenced by numerous factors, including global events and breaking news. When making a forecast about a stock’s future movement, traders typically look at recent price trends and market sentiment. By assessing the likelihood of price swings, we can make an informed forecast rather than a random guess.

Timeframe and accuracy: How long should you wait?

One critical aspect of forecasting stock prices that many traders overlook is the importance of timeframe. A common mistake is expecting immediate results. Let’s say you enter a trade with a stock in a strong, consistent uptrend. But just one hour after placing the trade, you see a $100 loss. What do you do?

The initial impulse is often to panic and make decisions driven by emotions, but reacting too quickly to short-term fluctuations is rarely helpful. Unless a significant event, like a natural disaster or geopolitical crisis, impacts the stock, a short-term loss shouldn’t be a reason to abandon your strategy. It’s essential to allow enough time for the stock to follow its trend, which could take weeks or even months.

Setting realistic expectations: Understanding stock volatility

When forecasting the price movements of a stock, it’s crucial to consider its historical chart and understand its price volatility. Every stock has a “price personality” – its typical price swings over time. This volatility can help set realistic price ranges for the stock, enabling you to determine where to place stop-loss orders or trailing stops.

For instance, if a stock typically fluctuates by 15-20%, setting a stop-loss order at 10% would likely trigger a sale unnecessarily. If your trade is intended to be a longer-term position, it’s important to allow more room for those natural fluctuations. As long as the stock maintains its uptrend, the position should eventually move in your favour.

Avoiding wishful thinking: Rely on facts, not hope

In the world of stock trading, wishful thinking and guesswork have no place. A successful trading strategy is rooted in careful analysis, data, and a clear understanding of the factors affecting stock prices. While it’s impossible to predict the future with absolute certainty, relying on facts over hope is a far more effective approach to forecasting stock movements. By making educated, well-informed decisions, traders can minimise risk and maximise the chances of success.

Forecast and track price movements of stocks with Trade Radar.

Trade Radar brandmark

Ready to get started? Sign up for a free trial >

Steve Carlsson, Trade Radar
Written by Steve Carlsson Founder & Director
18 Feb 2025

Share

Stay in the Loop

Stay ahead of the market – sign up for our latest product updates, news and more.

Newsletter Subscribe

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.